Home › Forums › Bais Medrash › Questions on Yoreh Deah, Choshen Mishpat › Reply To: Questions on Yoreh Deah, Choshen Mishpat
artchill:
siman 12 siif 1. A dayan does not have to judge an adam kashe unless he is the appointed public judge.
derech:
A.I was assuming it was at least mevashel kdei klipa. Hence for basar bchalav only the klipa would be issurei hanaa. But see yad avraham siman 87 that urui is not derech bishul so not min hatorah.
Another nafka mina is for shaar issurim whether we will say chaticha naaseis neveila according to taz in siman 92 that by lach blach if not cooked then no chanan
B. According to taz following maharshal in siman 105, kli sheni is mavlia kdei kulo. irui is more chamur so should do so as well. Why do we say irui only kdei klipa? Answer may be because tasaa gavar. See chavas daas 105:7 maharshal holds irui is kdei kulo, chavas daas objects on grounds of tasaa gavar.