Reply To: Can a Golem Speak?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Can a Golem Speak? Reply To: Can a Golem Speak?

#945014
nitpicker
Participant

to Talmud

blatantly incorrect! blatantly!?

I wish I could remember the name of the forger. I tell you he had already been caught . there is only one source for the story, a supposed find in a library many years after the maharal.

a) that isn’t enough and b) a bad source at that.

and don’t group me with old man on this, my stance on this issue is nothing like his.

and also to attribute that quote about believing stories to the Steipler is laughable. ( hedging as usual I say that it is possible that he subscribed to it and repeated it, but it is not his statement. that was a hedge, but I think it more likely it is just a mis-attribution )