Avi K -“Health,
1. The tiny yishuv could not possibly have withstood the Arabs in 5708 and 5727 or take in double it’s size in ten years without Hashem’s help.We will accept whomever He sends as shelichim (Me’ila 17a).”
B’derech Sh’odom Rozeh Moleichim Oso! Even Aveiros!
“2. A melech is not needed for a milchemet mitzva. This is proven by the fact that various judges conducted wars even before they became judges.”
It was all done by Nevuah. This was done against Hashem’s will.
“Anyway, according to Rav Kook any leader accepted by the people has the din of melech for these matters. This is also the mashmaut of the Netziv on the mitzva of appointing a king.In any case, all go into the army in a milchemet mitzva (Rambam Hilchot Melachim 7:4). The leader (whatever his technical title is) compels them if necessary (ibid 4:2).”
There is no Mitzva, but an Aveira to go to the IDF. This doesn’t have a Din of Milchemes Mitzva, no matter how many years you’ve been posting the same thing. And almost all the Gedolim disagreed with R’ Kook. Do you believe in Rov? If you add up all the Gedolim on the Anti-Medina side & all the ones Pro-Medina -you’ll find Most are against the Medina!