A dangerous road to go down, squeak. It would imply that tshuva might be the last resort of the wounded soul, but it offers nothing to the confident or strong.
Our community needs temporal leadership beyond its poskim. If its bright and capable are neither inspired enough to stay nor attracted enough to come back, we all have some serious cheshbon hanefesh to do to figure out why, and to come up with solutions that address yiddishkeit, not all of the “shmutz” out there that’s easy to blame.