Reply To: Satmer

Home Forums Controversial Topics Satmer Reply To: Satmer

#961611
HaKatan
Participant

DaMoshe, nice try with more meaningless rhetoric.

The criteria he gave for what makes one an apikores, according to what I quoted earlier, was one who celebrates the Israeli Yom HaAtzmaut. Nowhere in your story (assuming it is true), does it say that Rav Yaakov CH”V celebrated that Zionist “holiday”.

I am not interested in speculating on an unverified story, but he certainly was not condoning Zionism and ignoring the shmad, et al. of Zionism. Here is a quote from Rav Yaakov’s son about Rav Yaakov, as seen at Yated:

Regardless, Rav Yaakov was obviously not an apikores.