Reply To: About the RCA, I do shudder.

beninugman: I have not participated much in this discussion but it seems to me that -if what you say is correct about Rav Sherman’s psak- he actually “passels’ the Bais Din that accepted the geirus. I am not sure what is worse-to reject one’s geirus “post facto” (never done before) or his attempt to disqualify a qualified Bais Din. Remember, he tried to disqualify EVERY geirus that Rav Druckman’s Bais Din did. Is that logical?