Reply To: About the RCA, I do shudder.

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee About the RCA, I do shudder. Reply To: About the RCA, I do shudder.

#962179
nitpicker
Participant

to sam2.

it seems that we do know and that he was far frumer than his wife.

he moved voluntarily to ey after his wife left.

please note, it was not my intention to post a judgement of Rav Goren’s psak. what I wrote were simply facts that I thought were not at all in question, and I was surprised at your question. Who ever told rob he went back to his roots? yes, people claimed that, to prove he never meant to be mekabel mitsvos, but there is no evidence. It seems to have been made up at the time of the affair.

Rabannim made a point of inviting him for shabbos to show respect for him

to ROB who wrote “there was no bais din that paskend them for mamzerim”. I am sorry but that is revisionism. there certainly was.

and I remember them proclaiming that they were crying at the time of the case and they saw no way out.

and also to rob, of course you wouldn’t be aware of that tshuva, since it doesnt match your thesis.

of course rav moshe did everything to avoid mamzerus and to free agunos. that is what a rav is supposed to do. and rav moshe zatzal had a great koach l’hatir. but how dare you accuse him of just accepting or inventing silly heterim because the halacha is inconvenient!? he was an orthodox rabbi. are you?

and to poppa.

boy! you really started something here!