Reply To: Letter sent to Mishpacha magazine.

Home Forums Yeshiva / School / College / Education Issues Letter sent to Mishpacha magazine. Reply To: Letter sent to Mishpacha magazine.

#970414
HaKatan
Participant

rebdoniel:

It so happens that I humbly believe your understanding of the Rambam is not correct. But this is irrelevant to the matter at hand.

What is certainly clear from many great Rabbis (and the Rambam would certainly concur) is that Zionism was and is forbidden. One of the three oaths is to not hasten the redemption before its time. This applies even to excessive prayer, and certainly to actions on the ground. There could be other practices that help bring the redemption that are permitted. But founding a State far exceeds that which is halachicly permitted.

Seeking G-d in a manner that is very much against His will is obviously not a bright idea, no matter how much you wish to seek G-d.

ROB:

While Israel is indisputably a geopolitical fact, Zionism and its State is at least as treif now as it was in the past. Thus said many far greater Rabbis than, I daresay, even yourself, “Rabbi of Berlin”.

Your latest line that “we never know exactly what Hashem wants” as if to excuse Zionism because of that, is, at best, deception. You know very well what Hashem does NOT want. Yet because Hashem’s wishes, that are known from his Torah, conflict with your Zionist agenda, Zionists have this agenda take precedence over the Torah.

Zionists, yourself included, have no answers other than avoiding the truth, uncomfortable (for Zionists) as that truth may be.