Reply To: Why didn't Kaput Ha'ir work for me?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Why didn't Kaput Ha'ir work for me? Reply To: Why didn't Kaput Ha'ir work for me?

#985978
WIY
Member

Haleivi and others read this!

From Rabbi Eli Meyer Smith on Hakollel dot com

: Rivkah cried to Yaakov that he should

daven for her that she should have children, and if

the pain of being childless. She wanted Yaakov to

storm the Heavens with prayers in order to ease her

pain and guarantee her a child. This complaint

bothered Yaakov greatly because he knew that he

did not have the power himself to provide her with a

child. The prayers of tzadikim do not have to always

withholding a child from you. Hashem is withholding

mussar that she should not depend upon him alone.

He wanted to tell her that she herself should daven

and beseech Hashem for children. We see this later

in the verse (30:22), where it states: And Hashem

remembered Rochel. And Hashm listened to her and

he opened her womb. We see that she davened and

Hashem heard her prayers.

It is undoubtable that Yaakov davened for Rochel.

Yet, his tefillah went unanswered. Now, when she

complained that he must succeed with his tefillos

and grant her a child, he became upset at her and

told her that she must daven for children herself.

Rashi: Why did Yaakov get angry when Rochel asked

him to daven for her? He answers that Yaakov

of Hashem? Why do you want me to daven to

Hashem and ask Him to give you children through

my payers? You should daven yourself!

Yitzchok davened for Rivkah! Yaakov answered: I am

not like YItzchok. Yitzchok had no children. I have

children and cannot daven for something that I

already have. Even though we know that tzadikim

have the ability to daven for others, the Mizrachi

explains that tzadikim can only daven for something

that they do not have, or they can daven to Hashem

have. However, a tzadik cannot daven for something

related to him that he already has.

Rochel children? Because he already had children. If

he would daven for Rochel to have children, it would

also be a tefillah for himself to have more children.

have any. Yaakov could not daven for more children,

since he already had children.

Why is this so? Why can a person only daven for

something which he lacks, or for someone else for

something that person lacks, but not for himself for

something which he already has?

The verse in Parshas Vayeira, in the story of Hagar

and Yishmoel, says: And Hashem heard the voice of

the lad. Rashi quotes Chazal that say that we learn

from here that the prayers of a sick person are

superior to the prayers of others. The prayers of a

sick person are accepted sooner. Even though Hagar

the prayers of Yishmoel were accepted first. This is

because the sick person feels the pain and suffering.

Even if his tefillah is not said with very much

devotion, it is still a prayer from the depth of his

heart. Such a prayer is accepted quickly.