Reply To: Why does R' Yoichanan need a possuk for chatzi shi'ur?

Home Forums Bais Medrash Why does R' Yoichanan need a possuk for chatzi shi'ur? Reply To: Why does R' Yoichanan need a possuk for chatzi shi'ur?

#999428
dafbiyun
Participant

“the svarah is not a strong svarah”

There are two explanations for the svarah of chazi l’itztaryfai. According to the Tzlach ( and others) the Torah assered any amount since one might be oiver the issur kares by completing the shiur.

According to the Shagas Aryeh ( and others) the svarah is that if the torah gave kares for a full shiur then it is axiomatic that all of the components that got you to that shiur ( i.e. every little bite) must have been a cheftza shel issur.