Behavior during nuchem availim

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Behavior during nuchem availim

Viewing 48 posts - 1 through 48 (of 48 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2016843
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    I was at a bais ovel recently and two “talmiday chochim” met there and they loudly started to reminisce about the yeshiva days and sprinklered in with a few reden in lernen and totally ignored the availim, after 20 minutes of this they spoke 30 seconds to the availim said the posek and left.
    In an other bais ovel i recently went to a rosh yeshiva of a defunct mini yeshiva held court for a half hour on a monologe of his hashkafa in liife with the availim wanting him to stop and leave

    #2018068
    Goldilocks
    Participant

    That’s terrible.
    Someone should have asked them to leave.

    #2018133
    🍫Syag Lchochma
    Participant

    Common- can you help me out here? You aren’t 17 nor are you otd. So what’s with the “talmide chachamim” and “rosh yeshiva of a defunct mini yeshiva ” trash? You sound like a disgruntled teenager who needs to make sure to disparage rabbeim maximally when it has nothing to do with your point. What gives? I was 100% sure this was a troll post when I read it and am shocked you could produce this type of waste.

    #2018135
    ujm
    Participant

    I was about to post a comment when I noticed that Syag already posted exactly what I was about to say.

    #2018190
    AviraDeArah
    Participant

    Am I somehow living on an alternate plane where I don’t see bnei Torah constantly involved in abhorrent behavior, while my counterparts in a different plane see it everyday?

    #2018192
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    You right. The halacha is that the visitors are not suppose to speak until the aveilim speak.

    #2018194
    anonymous Jew
    Participant

    Syag, I’ve observed some odd behaviours at shiva houses. A friend and his father were sitting shiva for his mother and shadchanim came to check out the father. Real estate agents came to a friends shiva in Far Rockaway ( with his mother’s passing the house was going to be sold ) and handed out cards. Miahulachim from Israel came to our Rav’s shiva to sign their letters so they could go collecting in the community

    #2018193
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    @Syag, it really peved me that night and had to get it off my chest, sadly this not the first time I had seen this behavior, in this case both of the men who felt compelled to show off how learned they were.
    As to the former rosh yeshiva, if the guy had a bread route I doubt he would of held court as to what his haskafa is.

    #2018197
    Shimon Nodel
    Participant

    Syag, because knowing a lot of Torah or being iluyish doesn’t equate to being a talmid chacham. Anyone can be a rosh yeshiva too. That doesn’t automatically make you chashuv. Some people just want to be rebbish and caught up in the hock with their elite chevrah. That’s their simchas hachaim apparently..

    Really, the best thing to do in the beis avel is to shut your mouth unless you pick up a que that the avel wants to hear from you.

    #2018211
    🍫Syag Lchochma
    Participant

    Anon – not sure why you mention me for this story. My advice, move to a city where life runs differently.

    Shimon – missed the boat. I didn’t ask why their being learned bothered him, I asked why he felt an infantile need to elaborate on that point, and dis rabbaim while pretending to have a real point.

    CS – I feel your pain but you didn’t answer my question and frankly, pas nisht.

    #2018210
    Shimon Nodel
    Participant

    Avirah, it’s called illusory superiority. It was very popular in Germany. The maaleh isn’t with you, it’s with CS. He’s able to observe objectively.

    #2018215
    🍫Syag Lchochma
    Participant

    Um, no. sorry. There was nothing objective about his observation. Nor is getting something off your chest something you do in a public forum without taking 10 deep breaths and removal of anything that can look like chilul Hashem or bizayon. Just because it mirrored some of your posts and thoughts, that’s not the definition of objective.

    #2018218
    Shimon Nodel
    Participant

    Syag, I’m glad I missed the boat. I wouldn’t want to be stuck on it with you! (Jk)

    #2018297
    🍫Syag Lchochma
    Participant

    Common – I received an email from a personal moderator of my posts who felt I should cut you some slack. I apologize. Please be moichel.

    #2018382
    jackk
    Participant

    Syag,

    As a sign of mechila, CS should cut the 2 Talmiday chochomim and the Rosh Yeshiva some slack also and be dan them lcaf zchus. That is a mitzva min hatorah of being Dan Tzadikim Lcaf zchus.

    #2018424
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    @Syag, I was wrong at point out that they were “talminay chaochim” I said that as a point of reference, I would have been upset if two Baal batim met at a bais ovel and spent the time having a cross converation of the finer points of owning a Telsa or what the chances of a team winning the World Cup.


    @Jackk
    , I will be dan lcav zechus, and assume they were so happy to see each other and reminisce and talk in learning that they forgot they were in a bais ovel, and the former RY has no pulpit to expound his ideas.

    #2018415
    ujm
    Participant

    Or better yet, CS should focus his criticisms on mechalleli Shabbos rather than on Shomer Shabbos.

    #2018438
    🍫Syag Lchochma
    Participant

    Common – i hope mechilla was included in there. To your point, I felt your real topic got lost when it shouldn’t have. It is really so crucial and important. I sat shiva 3 times in 5 plus years and B”H never witnessed anything like that. I did develop a sense, tho, of how important it is to be focused on the availing, and how painful it can be for many of the ‘visitors’ who are suffering in their own way from the loss as well.

    #2018442
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    @UJM, if a shomer shabbos behaves like a idiot I will criticize him and if a mechall shabos behaves like an idiot I will do the same

    #2018433
    nishtdayngesheft
    Participant

    What is Nuchem Availim?

    #2018471
    jackk
    Participant

    I have been an Avel and visited many Beis Avel’s.
    A klal gadol is that no two Beis Avel’s are the same.

    #2018469
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    People sometimes keep their emotions bottled up, so chazal saw a means to be able to release it.

    #2018454
    FrumWhere
    Participant

    This is a very intriguing discussion. On the one hand, the complaint that it is childish and immature to feel a need to put down Talmidei Chachomim is quite valid. On the other hand, however, when foolish semi-learned and egoistic people create an atmosphere of embarrassment rather than one of Kovod HaTorah, they should perhaps be called out.

    The second scenario presented by CS is unfortunately common, and also not as incriminating as it sounds. Many times very learned leaders of young men (sometimes known as Rosh Yeshivas), especially elderly ones, have convinced themselves, justifiably or not, that they have “something valuable to impart”, no doubt due to the fact that they often do have valuable advice for their young charges, but not necessarily in other situations, like a beis ovel. Their unwelcome verbosity, ergo, often “goes with the territory”, and probably ought to be tolerated in normal situations.

    The first story presented, however, can be more problematic, since these “learned” fellows are seemingly violating clear halacha, and perhaps shouldn’t be shown much respect, but it really depends on the context. Let me explain.

    A number of years ago, a major out-of-town g’vir lost his wife, and many noted personalities came to the l’vaya. This g’vir was perhaps not from the greatest bnei Torah himself, and many of his friends were also rather uncouth. Right after the seudas havra’ah, the ovel sat down in his living room for the first nichum aveilm, together with some members of his wife’s family. Immediately, in a poorly-orchestrated effort to “cheer him up”, a number of his crass friends started making foolish and inappropriate jokes and remarks, with the ovel himself laughing along with them, which created a very embarrassing situation for his poor father-in-law and brothers-in-law, not to mention the many venerable Rabbonim and Roshei Yeshivos in the room. After a few minutes of this, a number of the talmidei chachomim there began quietly conversing among themselves, in effect “tuning out” the un-Torah-like atmosphere around them, and after a short while, they stood up and “spoke 30 seconds to the availim said the posek and left.” Sounds familiar?

    Pay attention to the context.

    #2018487
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    Nichum availim unites by recognizing that a person is not an island and requires sometimes the help of others.

    #2018496
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    @syag, Of course I am mochel, and I hope you afford the same to me when I say something harsh.

    @Frumwhere
    , hardly the case here, it was in a stable chusiver household, it was that these two men felt that the cross conversation was important enough for all to hear even if no one was interested

    #2018504
    Gadolhadorah
    Participant

    So, someone just realized that even the most “chashuvah” rabbonim and askanim can sometimes act like jerks? It happens all the time and makes you wonder why they are referenced as “chashuvah” or have other various honorifics imputed to them. I have been to levayahs where the hesped is more about the person giving the hesped than the niftar, shidduchin where the mesader kidushin stumbles over the brachos because he was “mesamach” choson v’kallah before the festivities officially began. That’s life. It happens all to frequently. Not much you can do other than find ways to quietly intervene and lessen the impact of such boorish behavior on the the aveilim, baalei Simcha etc.

    #2018618
    nishtdayngesheft
    Participant

    GH,

    You are an out and out liar. I do not for a moment believe you have seen any of the following occur by people bnei torah call chashuv. Perhaps people of your ilk, who you might consider choshuv (you even call yourself a Gadol! And you are clearly the furthest from that.)

    “I have been to levayahs where the hesped is more about the person giving the hesped than the niftar, shidduchin where the mesader kidushin stumbles over the brachos because he was “mesamach” choson v’kallah before the festivities officially began.”

    #2018666
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    @nist, Unforturantly I can vouch about the ramblings at a levayah, there was the head of chedra kadisha in a certain area who use to be mapid and ramble on about himself

    #2018681
    Shimon Nodel
    Participant

    Nisht,

    You’re part of the problem. That’s all I need to say here

    #2018721
    nishtdayngesheft
    Participant

    Noodles,

    Really? GH continuously makes false allegations about and denigrates bnei torah, talmidei chachomim and upright people, and calling him on his lies is the problem?

    Really, Reb Shimon, think this one through.

    #2018753
    Gadolhadorah
    Participant

    Nisht: I promise not to refer to you as a “chashuvah poster”.
    And yes, I’ve unfortunately experienced exactly what I described. And no, its no disrespect to the vast majority of rabbonin and askanim who conduct themselves with the utmost sensitivity to the occasion to observe that unfortuantely, as the OP noted, there are as surprising number who don’t. A ben torah (chashuvah or not) can sometimes act like a jerk just as a poishete yid can act with great sensitivity, charm and respect. Hopefully, you will only know from simchas so you will never have to deal with shivahs and aveilim.

    #2018826

    GH> ben torah (chashuvah or not) can sometimes act like a jerk

    I disagree. There are multiple quotes about Talmidei Chachamim that we can use as a definition of the term, such as T Ch merabim shalom b’olam. That is someone who is not doing that, is not one.

    In particular, if you see T’Ch doing averah in the evening, you don’t need to give him tochacha next day, as he surely did teshuva. From this, we see that T’Ch can do an avera, but he will not do it repeatedly or habitually.

    #2018832
    Gadolhadorah
    Participant

    AAQ.. Good points but perhaps its my clumsy use of terminology. A rav or askan may not be “doing an averah” nor will he always be aware that the type of behavior described by common saychel in his OP and others posters may have caused pain or stress to the aveilim (or in the other context, embarrassed baaeli simcha). Neither the OP nor subsequent posters in this thread suggested that this happens on a “regular basis” but this kind of stuff DOES happen. I would imagine that the immediate remedy is generally to focus on providing support and comfort for the aveilim and not to confront or give musar to the offender.

    #2018932
    nishtdayngesheft
    Participant

    GH,

    I would refer to my comment above, where I talk about being defined as Choshuv by bnei torah.

    I doubt someone who is completely clueless about how two brothers marrying two sisters applies to Maseches Yevamos could possibly be construed as a ben torah. Vda”l.

    #2019068
    Lostspark
    Participant

    This has to be the highest horse ever ridden in the CR.

    Common Saychel I’m sure it would be too much of a safer for you to stand in the presence of an elderly gentleman on account he may have committed avieros in his youth.

    #2019089
    Lostspark
    Participant

    *safek

    #2019091
    Shimon Nodel
    Participant

    My great grandfather and his brother actually did marry two sisters! 😄 true story

    #2019124
    commonsaychel
    Participant

    @lostpark, with all due respect I have no clue what you are saying

    #2020354
    gilda
    Participant

    People have a tendency at shiva to ask dumb questions like how long was he sick how long did he take treatments etc. We have to say nice things about the niftar and be sympathetic

    #2020386
    HaLeiVi
    Participant

    @glida, I don’t think there’s anything wrong about speaking of what they’re actually mourning. If you have real insight about this I’ll hear you out, but I’ve stood by, as well as joined, such conversations. That’s actually part of being sympathetic. Can you just sit there and just go hmm phmm?

    #2020379
    ujm
    Participant

    Gilda: There’s nothing wrong about asking regarding the niftar’s illness.

    #2020400
    gilda
    Participant

    I find People are sometimes not comfortable discussing details of the illness. But saying nice things about the person can be a real nechama.

    #2020484
    ujm
    Participant

    Other times they are very comfortable and happy to discuss the niftar’s illness.

    #2020512
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    To deal with the loss, we must talk about the circumstances.

    #2020510
    Gadolhadorah
    Participant

    Without regards to the names of any particular CR posters, in any of these circumstances, once you arrive “read the room”, get a feel for the mood, the people there at that time, the substance and tone of the ongoing conversation and use COMMON SENSE. Spend a few minutes listening to the conversation before ASKING QUESTIONS or trying to direct the conversation in another direction. As one poster above noted, most important, lead with positive memories of the niftar, and if possible, recall some special anecdote about your personal interaction with him/her that will provide nechama to the aveilim.

    #2020551
    nishtdayngesheft
    Participant

    “Read the room”?

    There is a reason why halacha is to let the availim start the conversation. You are not going on a marketing visit, that you should need to read the room.

    #2020565
    Gadolhadorah
    Participant

    Use another term but “reading the room” means situational awareness. Both halacha and common sense dictate listening to what the aveilim and others already engaged in conversation are saying before you speak. In some cases there may not be much being said and to break the silence you have to offer your words of nechama with great care and sensitivity to how those words are received.

    #2020715

    > two sisters applies to Maseches Yevamos could possibly be construed as a ben torah.

    It used to be, a talmid chacham was allowed to hide knowledge of learning a particular maseches. Now, it leads to ridicule.

Viewing 48 posts - 1 through 48 (of 48 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.