Brooklyn Eruv

Why wouldn’t you need to make eruv tavshilin in Brooklyn?

Well then, anywhere within the techum of Brooklyn would be OK.

bump

Outside what eruv?

Was this during leining?

Popa carries on Shabbos. He carries on Sunday, he carries on Monday, he carries on Tuesday…

Popa is constantly carrying on.

You carried yourself?

Is this a riddle?

I didn’t see him.

Boy, its like you folks have never read a dan l’kaf zchus story.

Harumph….as if we all accused you of being mechallel Shabbos. I said you were “carrying on”, ivory said you were carrying yourself, hashtagposter said, ” #!”, and 29 said you were in rishus hayochid (then I made a dumb joke about you not being in my rishus).

These were all more reasonable innocent explanations than that you had an ulcer.

Also, make up your mind; was it a karmelis, or r’shus horabbim?

If you look at your post, you’re the one who classified yourself as a rasha! And were all looking for limud zechus for you so I dono what you’re griping about!

Ill assume your kidding.. But you wouldn’t be allowed to carry security blankets etc for a woman in labor

Also DY: haven’t you ever read a dan l’af zchus story where the guy is fressing chazer and also tells you he doesn’t have an ulcer and he isn’t starving to death and his doctor said he’d better stay away from chazer, and there’s nobody who told him he’d better eat it or he’s dead?

Is this the one you’re talking about?:

Rabbi Goldberg sees Yankel in shul, and tells him, “Yankel, we have to talk”.

“What is it, Rabbi”?

“I saw you eating in a treif restaurant yesterday”.

“Rabbi, you’ve got to be dan me l’kaf z’chus, like you always talk about in your drashos”.

“Yankel, I wish I could, but I saw the whole thing. I saw you walk in, I saw it was a treif restaurant. I checked the menu; they sell all sorts of treif things like chazzer, shellfish, cholov stam, and Twizzlers without a sticker. I saw you order chazzer roast, I saw you eating it, and I saw you paying for it with your American Express card which you use every year to donate money to the shul on Small Business Saturday. So tell me Yankel, how can I possibly be dan you l’kaf z’chus?”

“Easily”, says Yankel, “the whole thing was under rabbinical supervision!”

I was mechalel shabbos. Several times that day. I use a midwife at a hospital who works with a doctor. I called the midwife, probably twice. She called the doctor. I called the cab, too. I didn’t have to sign in tho cuz they knew I couldn’t so they let me make an ‘x’ with my left hand. And I definitely was outside the eiruv because we don’t have one.

have no idea. I don’t think they can deny service, but they CAN send you through the “no insurance” system which would include whichever doctor happens to be on call. Either way, it’s been 20 years and there are many more frum people giving birth there so things have probably changed.

A reminder to put up a Brooklyn Eiruv?

LF: What do the signs say?

You should be dan l’kaf z’chus that in the tallis bag there were supplies for a choleh sheyesh bo sakanah.

If you live in Brooklyn (or if you don’t), please remember to make an Eruv Tavshilin.

GAON
Are yous aying those in Brooklyn don need to make an Eruv Tavshilin?

Ok so DY is right “If you live in Brooklyn (or if you don’t), please remember to make an Eruv Tavshilin.”

You asked
“What does Brooklyn have with Eruv Tavshilin?”

Like DY said If yo ulive in brooklyn or if yo udont …