- This topic has 12 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 8 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Is charoses not the best part of pesach?
im ob with charoses!! i would take a koraich sandwich to school for lunch….
For sure!!! That and grandchildren!
I’m confused. Charoses in not eaten, the maror is dipped in it and then it is shaken off.
“Charoses in not eaten.” Oh it’s eaten, just depends how hard you do the shaking. What’s the point of the shulchan aruch giving a delicious recipe if it’s not going to be eaten?
Is charoses not the best part of pesach?
No, it is not.
Charoses in not eaten
I am not aware of any halacha that says that charoses cannot be eaten during the meal or at any other time during Pesach.
But then again, knowing me, if I think it’s permitted, it’s probably actually forbidden as yehoraig v’al ya’avor.
The Wolf
Wolf: I didn’t mean that it is assur, but on the other hand I am not aware of any source in Gemara, Sefrei Halacha or Sifrei Minhagim that it should be eaten So I am surprised that some people consider an antidote to the “poison” of maror an intrinsic, or “best” part of the whole Pesach.
Wolf: I didn’t mean that it is assur, but on the other hand I am not aware of any source in Gemara, Sefrei Halacha or Sifrei Minhagim that it should be eaten So I am surprised that some people consider an antidote to the “poison” of maror an intrinsic, or “best” part of the whole Pesach.
There’s no source in the Gemara, Sifrei Halacha or Sifrei Minhagim about singing Dayenu, yet most families do it and some people view it as the highlight of the seder. So what? The OP happens to like the taste of charoses and, for him/her, it’s the best part. For me, it’s not. Live and let live.
The Wolf
The Wolf
Of course its eaten, its the best desert.
I used to hate charoses more than the maror. It was the walnuts. I hated walnuts since I was a young kid.
Recently I switched to slivered almonds, and sweet apples and dates, and it was so delicious I couldn’t get enough. I rationalized that we are sweetening the bitter, and this is the goal of life.
I LOVE charoses, cannot get enough of it and would never dream of making it any time of year but for the sedarim, so yes, it is certainly up in the top three of best things on Pesach.
Unfortunately, for now I cannot make charoses with nuts added to the apples, wine, cinnamon, and ginger. Nevertheless, my charoses has always drawn raves in my family and among my invited guests, and despite the missing ingredient, was still very well received this year.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.