- This topic has 13 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 4 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Can it?
It can.
It’s the machashava behind it.
It’s the machashava behind it.
So if someone spreads kefira, without having intended to, it’s okay??
Define “halachic kefira”.
This is a post, hence it’s kefirah.
Yep, I see the logic behind that. : rolleyes :
The Wolf
So if someone spreads kefira, without having intended to, it’s okay??
I didn’t say kavana (intention), I said machshava (thought).
Define “halachic kefira”
Kefirah is a thought/belief which is inconsistent with a basic tenet of Yiddishkeit, for example, the 13 ikarim according to the Ramba”m, as enumerated in his pirush on Perek Chelek.
This is a post, hence it’s kefirah.
Yep, I see the logic behind that. : rolleyes :
An overreaction, I think, considering that the OP simply mistakenly used the word “does” in place of “can”.
An overreaction, I think, considering that the OP simply mistakenly used the word “does” in place of “can”.
It’s something that changes the entire meaning of the question. I simply answered it accordingly.
The Wolf
The 13 ikarim have not been universally accepted, but that is for another thread. What you describe is hashkafah kefira. What is halachic kefira?
That’s why I wrote “according to the Ramba”m”.
I believe the OP meant something that would be considered, according to halacha, kefira.
Can the mods change “does” to “can” in the title so that it CAN make sense
TYIA
You’re welcome. -95
There should be no Kefirah in a moderated YWN Coffeeroom blog, and if there is it is fully the fault of the moderator for doing the final step of releasing it.
Charlie: Halachic kefira is an opinion that renders its proponents kofrim according to halacha. For example, one who believes that there was a prophet greater than Moshe would be a kofer according to nearly all opinions.
I simply answered it accordingly.
The eye-roll was a bit much. ?
ItcheSrulik,
Thank you.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.