Jewish Perspective on Humans Controlling Nature

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Jewish Perspective on Humans Controlling Nature

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #612492
    streekgeek
    Participant

    What is the Torah’s veiw on humans using their intelligence to control nature? I’m not talking about cross breeding and other ways of control that the Torah speaks explicitly against; rather controlling aspects of nature as a sort of “damage control”, like seeding clouds, changing the direction in which a body of water flows… Is this something we, as Jews, condone. Do we support the scientists’ dreams of a stable utopia where humans are in control of everything?

    #1020341
    streekgeek
    Participant

    Mods –

    Not sure where that J went in the thread title…could you add it in?

    #1020342
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Humans naturally try to control nature.

    #1020343
    benignuman
    Participant

    My understanding hashkafically is that the Torah is in favor of humans manipulating and improving nature for the betterment of humans. We are partners in creation.

    There is a maaseh brought down in the Gemara where a Roman argued to Rabbi Akiva that bris milah was a perversion of the nature that Hashem created. Rabbi Akivah brought the Roman a cake and asked the Roman if he would rather eat a slice of cake or chew some wheat, raw eggs, raw sugar, drink some oil, etc. The Roman got the point.

    I don’t think humanity will ever be fully in control of everything but it is certainly noble to try and harness nature for the betterment of as many people as possible.

    #1020344
    Chortkov
    Participant

    There is a similar maaseh brought down where somebody asked one of the tanoim about why it is correct to heal the sick – if G-d gave them an illness, apparently it is His will that they be sick. The Tanah answered with the same analogy, by giving him some wheat and telling him to eat it raw.

    Apparently, regarding things that are in our capacity to control, HKB”H gave us the abilities to enable us to control.

    #1020345
    ED IT OR
    Participant

    Some people think its human nature to be controlling

    #1020346
    streekgeek
    Participant

    yekke2 – Apparently, regarding things that are in our capacity to control, HKB”H gave us the abilities to enable us to control.

    But there are many things we can control, but are against the Torah.

    benignuman – We are partners in creation.

    Assuming this is correct (that we are actually partners in creation), where do we draw the line? If people can and do control everything, it will inevitably lead to feelings of “kochi v’otzem yadi”, and lack of awareness that there is a Greater Force running nature.

    #1020347
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    That is just silly, streekgeek. We are able to control nature to some extent because we are part of it. People will never be able to control everything, and we needn’t worry about that. We can control our attitudes, but we don’t have to limit our abilities.

    #1020348
    ChiYid
    Member

    The question doesn’t really start. HKB”H created nature including effective influences on nature. For instance a chemical reaction when combining 2 or more substances changes it’s very nature but that ability was also create during maase braishis. So if we learned to control the weather, that would also have to have been part of the Master Plan. Now, what’s your question?

    #1020349
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    Let’s change the title to Perspective on Jews Controlling Nature. That should earn us a neonazi link.

    #1020350
    HaLeiVi
    Participant

    The Issur of Klayim is not because it is immoral. It is a Chok. We have no problem buying Klayim from a non-Jew in Chutz Laaretz. The only type of fooling around with the world that is Assur is Kishuf, since it is called Makchishim Pamalya Shel Maala — it is going against the system designed by Hashem. Doing things naturally is within the system.

    #1020351
    streekgeek
    Participant

    So if we learned to control the weather, that would also have to have been part of the Master Plan. Now, what’s your question?

    Why is that the Master Plan? Why would Hashem create a perfect world that is ultimately self sufficient in the humans’ eyes. Isn’t that defeating the whole purpose of the creation (which as I learnt is to see Yad Hashem in everything around us)? How can we be expected to see Hashem in nature if it is being controlled? Why is it okay in Judaism to control nature to such an extreme extent?

    #1020352
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Because we’re not controlling nature, we’re working with it, following it’s laws, discovering more about it.

    #1020353
    benignuman
    Participant

    streetgeek,

    I don’t think people can and do control everything, or ever will. But that doesn’t mean that they shouldn’t try and control nature for the benefit of mankind. Furthermore, this doesn’t mean that Hashem isn’t ultimately in control.

    Dealing with kochem v’otzem yadi is a nisayon that we are meant to deal with. There is no gezeira that I am aware of to the effect that we should not harness nature for a good purpose becuase it might lead to kochem v’otzem yadi.

    #1020354
    Shopping613 🌠
    Participant

    Everything is in control. Just not ours. 🙂

    – My teacher

    Everything is min hashomayim cept from yiras shomayim,

    #1020355
    Sam2
    Participant

    streekgeek: There is a Gemara that references that they changed the way a river flows. It has Halachic Nafka Minas, but nowhere did the Gemara seem to indicate (as I recall) that it was something that shouldn’t have been done.

    #1020356
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Beavers do stuff like that all the time.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.