- This topic has 13 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 4 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Has anyone heard about a letter signed by the Gedoli Yisrael soon after the foundation of the State of Israel that asserted that the state itself is the beginning of the redemption? If so, is this letter authentic?
I believe I heard there was such a forgery.
Both Chazon Ish and Brisker Rav, who were there, stated that the State was a bad “gzeira”. Others held similarly.
The letter is authentic. As was the letter about saying Hallel on Yom Ha’atzma’ut in 1949. It was signed by people like R’ Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, R’ Elyashiv, R’ Kahaneman, and others. I think I once saw a reproduction of it on the internet but I don’t remember where.
Now, that is not to say that it was unanimous. The Brisker and Satmar Rovs most famously, along with many others, were opposed to the state before, during, and after its inception. But there were many who felt that the state was a good thing when it first happened.
There was a famous zionist forgery of a letter with signatures of many rabbis who never signed it.
I think the seforim blog once was maarich that it is forged.
There was a letter, but not everybody held like that. The fanatical anti-Zionists (HaKatan, the multi-headed dragon of Josef etc.) will attempt to claim there was none. Don’t believe them!
OP, you see what you did? Joe is going out of his keilim.
The post on the Seforim Blog is called “Kalir, False Accusations, and More
by Marc B. Shapiro” in middle of number 2 he mentions the letter.
There really was a letter, but the key language -that the state is “reishis tzemichas geulosainu”- is believed to have been added after many of the Gedolim had already signed.
Chacham: I’m shocked that you read the Seforim Blog (though there is a lot of great stuff on there; Menachem Butler is an absolute genius). But that is a good thing to see. Interesting. I’ve seen the letter so many places and never heard anyone say it wasn’t legit. It was about the elections and not Hallel though. I did forget that part.
Whether it is to say Hallel or it is to vote in Elections is a humongous difference.
The fact they felt a need to forge what the letter said and edit it, speaks volumes to their realization that they lacked support in their position.
The whole state is a forgery. It doesn’t really exist.
Let me ask you this: If a jewish state existed, do you really think there would be only one knesset?
mdd, as I wrote, I believe there was a letter, but there were a number of “irregularities” that invalidate it.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.