- This topic has 11 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 8 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
For those that keep promoting that no one should force their chumras upon others, you surely would say that no one should push people to daven with a minyan, right? After all, if someone davens at home seven days a week, three times a day, he is fulfilling his halachic requirements for tefila. All those chumradik people who daven with a minyan are no better than those who never daven with a minyan (but always daven.)
So, please, don’t push your chumras on the minyan-less.
Joseph:
Better to be quiet and be thought a fool, than to speak and remove all doubt.
You have removed all doubt (not as if we had any doubt before, but just in case we did).
Ayin SA OHC Siman 90.
greatest: One of the halachic requirements for tefillah is tefillah betzibur. If someone davens without a minyan, he is yotzei tefillah, but not tefillah betzibur. If someone davens the whole Amidah without kavanah (except the first beracha), he is yotzei his chiyuv of tefillah; yet, the halacha requires kavanah for the whole thing. If someone forgot Ya’aleh Veyavo for Rosh Chodesh at Ma’ariv, he is yotzei; however, the halacha requires him to have said it. etc.
Why do I bother?
What makes you think that Davening with Minyan is only a Chumra?
Davening with a minyan is a chiyuv.
If you’re somewhere where there’s no minyan, there’s no chiyuv to find a minyan.
or an esrog. zdad, your mental acuity continues to baffle me. you, holmes, and einstein.
Exactly how do I fit in this conversation?
Your sinas Chinan continues to baffle me
whoops, honest mistake. it was late at night and i read avhaben as you. and i dont hate you, Cvs, i just hate when you make bad tzushtells that are totally off topic.
measure for measure. -Shakespeare
I highly doubt Toi hates Chinan although I cant be sure of it.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.