November 30, 2011 12:57 am at 12:57 am #600901ironpenguinMember
Seminary in Israel costs 18,000 and up. How are we supposed to pay for it? Does anyone know of scholarships available for seminaries? Do seminaries work with you for financial aid or is it pay or don’t come?November 30, 2011 2:13 am at 2:13 am #831129sam4321Participant
Did you ever check into MASA they have a website.November 30, 2011 2:17 am at 2:17 am #8311302scentsParticipant
Why go to Isreal if you cannot afford it?November 30, 2011 2:19 am at 2:19 am #831131farrockawayParticipant
Don’tNovember 30, 2011 2:20 am at 2:20 am #831132golden momMember
ask around there is alot of finacial assistance for this and sems do not work w u its a cash business and they want all of it in greenNovember 30, 2011 4:43 am at 4:43 am #831133WIYMember
If your father can’t afford it then don’t go. You are still young but realize that $18000 is a lot of money in this day and age (to make) and its not fair to expect your father to “cough” it up for you so you can have fun in EY for a year. This whole mishigass is not sustainable and I hope all of these Seminaries close down. People can’t afford them and it causes unnecessary financial strain on people.November 30, 2011 6:00 am at 6:00 am #831134real-briskerMember
WIY – That was a not nice klullah. I would retract what you said and say it in a nicer fashion.November 30, 2011 1:34 pm at 1:34 pm #831135old manParticipant
I hope all the seminaries stay open and that all parents have enough money to send each daughter to seminary in Israel. To deny them this opportunity is to deny them a major part of our heritage.
That said, if you can’t afford it, don’t go. It is wrong to spend money that doesn’t exist, and more wrong to exploit other people’s money for your own purposes.November 30, 2011 2:12 pm at 2:12 pm #831136gavra_at_workParticipant
If your father can’t afford it then don’t go. You are still young but realize that $18000 is a lot of money in this day and age (to make) and its not fair to expect your father to “cough” it up for you so you can have fun in EY for a year. This whole mishigass is not sustainable and I hope all of these Seminaries close down. People can’t afford them and it causes unnecessary financial strain on people.
I second. Seminaries are in it for the money.
(Have I said before that I don’t like Sems?)November 30, 2011 3:25 pm at 3:25 pm #831137mytakeMember
“If your father can’t afford it then don’t go. You are still young but realize that $18000 is a lot of money in this day and age (to make) and its not fair to expect your father to “cough” it up for you so you can have fun in EY for a year. This whole mishigass is not sustainable and I hope all of these Seminaries close down. People can’t afford them and it causes unnecessary financial strain on people.”
Well said, WIY.November 30, 2011 3:37 pm at 3:37 pm #831138cherrybimParticipant
There are too many unknown variables for anyone to offer useful advice.November 30, 2011 4:57 pm at 4:57 pm #831139littleappleMember
Masaisrael.org income threshold $10K per family member, $4-5K grant if attending eligible sem.
Pell grant available, sliding scale upto $4-5K if attending eligible sem. as Touro Israel student, also Skokie Sem possible.
TAP grant available for NYS residents.
The above can potentially bring price down to under $9K for a great year in E.Y. and the student came come back with close to two years of college credit, this actually makes the year in sem. very sensible and a big savings for qualified people.November 30, 2011 5:03 pm at 5:03 pm #831140
“I hope all the seminaries stay open and that all parents have enough money to send each daughter to seminary in Israel. To deny them this opportunity is to deny them a major part of our heritage.”
What major part of our heritage would they be denied exactly? When did Seminary for girls become part and parcel of frumkeit, in the last 30 years? Look up the definition of heritage.November 30, 2011 5:06 pm at 5:06 pm #831141
Don’t go. Look for other alternatives. Seminaries can charge whatever they want because people will pay. Stop sending the girls and you’ll see how quickly tuition drops.November 30, 2011 6:08 pm at 6:08 pm #8311422scentsParticipant
it prepares them for life.. (gimme a break!)November 30, 2011 7:54 pm at 7:54 pm #831143Ananas12Member
how much is a sem in US ?December 1, 2011 1:26 am at 1:26 am #831144daughterofHashemMember
2scents- it prepared me for life!December 1, 2011 2:15 am at 2:15 am #831145yentingyentaParticipant
sem in america ranges. monsey i think is like 6, yavne including boarding is about 11. maalot baltimore is prob in the same range. factor in though more frequent travel/commutingDecember 1, 2011 2:40 am at 2:40 am #831146
daughterofHashem- can you tell us how it prepared you for life?December 1, 2011 3:26 am at 3:26 am #831147trak443Member
There are numerous ways to pay for sem.
MASA and TAP/PELL are the big well-known ones.
MASA is funded by the Israeli govt. therefore, some more right-wing seminaries will not accept it. Everyone is eligible for $1000. For americans, if your income falls below $22500 per person in the household (even boys learning out of town) then you are eligible for either $3700 or $4000 depending on whether the seminary school year is 9 months or 10 months long that year. (For example: If you have 8 kids (somaich al shulchunno) then if your combined gross income is $224,999 or less, you are eligible for the full 3700/4000). For those residing outside the USA, the amount is considerably more. (I have no idea why.)
MASA, too, can only be applied for, after the beginning of the year (Jan).
PELL is federally funded and is income based. Go to fafsa.gov after the beginning of the year (Jan) and once you have done your taxes, and file online. I takes approx 20-30 minutes. Max available: approx $5500.
TAP is for NYS residents only. (When you fill out your info on fafsa.gov, they offer to automatically send your info to TAP.) Max available: approx $4500.
HOWEVER, to be “eligible” for TAP/PELL, besides income, you need to be registered in a college. Seminaries, by themselves are NOT institutions. There are currently three colleges that have an “Israel program”.
a) Touro. Registration in Touro requires (I think) an 85 average plus an you must take an SAT (starting in 2010) and get either a 1400 or 1600, I don’t remember. Registration cost $1500 (last year). Acceptance into the Touro/Israel option makes NYS residents eligible for both TAP and PELL. (www.touro.edu)
b) HTC/TI (Hebrew Theological College/Torah Institiute) is in Skokie, IL, so you are only eligible for PELL. I really don’t remember their academic requirements, but they do require an SAT score. Registration $1500. (www.htc.edu)
c) MJI (Michigan Jewish Institute) is located in Southfield, MI. Again, since it’s outside NY, you are only eligible for PELL. I don’t think you need an SAT. Registration (I think) is $2500, but as far as I remember, they only charge you a small part of it up front, and the rest they take out when paying out the remainder to the seminary. So there is less “out of pocket”. (www.mji.edu)
When registered with one of the above, the seminary year is probably good for approx 30+ college credits. For those eligible for MASA ($4000) TAP ($4500) and PELL ($5500), for approx $4K it’s a very good deal, besides you get to be in Eretz Yisrael.
For those NOT eligible for TAP/PELL, due to the economy, SOME seminaries are open to VERY SERIOUS discounts.
Meohr has a program where you can have your Charter Oak College accept Meohr classes for credit. (cost: approx $300).
Additionally, Execelsior now accepts Tiferes (NOT Ateres) and Peninim’s transcripts AS IS for college credit. There is currently NO cost for this.
Reizel Reit is working on an ISRAEL program, that will also help those who don’t want to go thru Touro etc.. but that won’t be up and running in time for this year.
Additonally, there are many private scholarships available. (Toyota, Walmart, Coca Cola etc….)
To address those who are bothered by the cost of the seminary year, a few points.
1. Take the cost of tuition in the USA, and add in all the additional costs of room, board, and travel, (plus the college credits) and suddenly it’s a pretty good deal.
2. Have you ever heard of a seminary supplementing their tuition with an annual dinner, like your local mossad does?
3. Nobody is forcing you to send your daughter. If you feel there is a perceived peer-pressure, GET OVER IT. HANDLE IT LIKE A MATURE ADULT. Don’t knock every one else who can afford it. I personally can’t, so my daughter who was motivated, worked very hard babysitting etc.. thru high school and paid for 2/3 of it herself.
4. Seminary is a business. Just like your local bagel store, supermarket, insurance broker, mechanic, seforim store, Walmart etc…… Not just that, but it’s a luxury business. So, if you can’t afford it, just move on. Just like you would walk past the Jaguar dealership. Skip the sour grapes.They are entitled to make a living. And they do make a DECENT living. I am privvy to what goes on behind the scenes, and they do well, no doubt about it. But they are not flying around in the private jets or even in first class. It’s a business, and they are entitled to charge what they can. Again, supply and demand. Think it’s so easy? Start a seminary yourself!
Having said that, they are subject to the same laws of capitalism as everyone else in the free world. So, if there wasn’t a demand, they wouldn’t be there (and constantly opening new programs). That doesn’t mean that everyone should go. Some kids cannot and should not be trusted on their own. Some are more mature than others. but many others do grow a lot in both maturity and in ruchnius.December 1, 2011 3:55 am at 3:55 am #831148daughterofHashemMember
Bowwow- Sure, it taught me responsibility, independence, how to stick through things that are hard and make the best of any situation (my roommates), it taught me how to live with other people….all this besides for the better knowledge of myself and who i am, and how to build a closer connection with Hashem. I don’t think 20 grand is a waste for all that…IF you can afford it. If you can’t you will learn these life lessons other ways and its not worth putting your parents in debt!December 1, 2011 4:00 am at 4:00 am #831149cinderellaMember
“Nobody is forcing you to send your daughter. If you feel there is a perceived peer-pressure, GET OVER IT. HANDLE IT LIKE A MATURE ADULT. Don’t knock every one else who can afford it.”
+1December 1, 2011 5:05 am at 5:05 am #831150inspiredteenMember
I know that many people are against seminary. Every time I see it, it makes me sad because there is so much to gain! Ask any girl who had a good year in seminary, and she will most likely tell you that 1) she can’t imagine how she would be if she hadn’t gone 2) she couldn’t have done the same thing at home or in the US. Its an experience like none other.
If you can’t afford it, try all the grants and stuff. And then speak to the seminary. If you are a serious girl who is not gonna waste her year, they might be willing to help you out. There are also academic scholarships and ones depending on what your parents do. Don’t give up so fast on going. And, the harder you work for it, the more you will appreciate it and gain from it.December 1, 2011 6:12 am at 6:12 am #831151sem graduateMember
I went to sem in Eretz Yisroel and loved it. I grew a lot from the experience and changed completely in ways that I could not have changed at home. The sems are usually willing to work with you about the tuition if you have a problem paying for it. I would very strongly endorse trying…December 1, 2011 6:47 am at 6:47 am #831152goodbyeMember
look into beis yaakov mezuraz. it’s a 5-6 month program, and cuts the cost by almost half. it’s also a really great seminary. check it out.December 1, 2011 4:39 pm at 4:39 pm #831153littleappleMember
I can testify to the truth of Trak443 conclusions we received the scholarships and it was not just affordable but a bargain because the sem was a very hard working one and she came back with 55 college credits, yes in Jewish studies but still cutting future degree costs considerably.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.