- This topic has 12 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
My son is nine and a half and still wets the bed every night. To keep the mattress dry we have him wear pullups training pants from pampers. They have a special feature on them that when they get wet the picture will fade. Is that a problem of moichek on shabbos? If yes what should I get him instead?
Why is that feature there?
You need to ask a real posek, not the CR, but off the top of my head, it’s ??? ?????, and if it’s ?? ???? ??? (which is why I asked the purpose of it fading) it shouldn’t be a problem. It’s a big if, though.
I’m not a rabbi, but off hand I can think of a bunch of factors that would make it not a problem:
1) If he’s sleeping when it happens, it’s probably Mis’asek (or maybe less)
2) It’s a Melocho She’eina Tzricha L’gufa
3) It’s probably considered Kil’achar Yad
4) Is Mocheik even a problem with pictures (not words)?
I’m sure there’s more…
I don’t know what the halacha is regarding these fading designs, but Goodnites doesn’t have them.
The feature is there as a wetness indicator to tell him if he’s wet. Also as a side it gives him the will to stay dry as he doesn’t want the picture to fade.
The first might be considered nicha lei, the second wouldn’t be.
Meno, there is koseiv and mochek on pictures.
“”I’m sure there’s more…
He is a kattan.
Please don’t put him in diapers. Pull- ups are bad enough for his confidence.
Have you tried waking him in middle of the night to go the bathroom? It’s very hard to time it just right, but worth a shot.
The good news is that he’ll outgrow it IY”H, the bad news is that it may still take a couple of years. Hatzlacha!
“I’m not a rav but…”
stop right there.
Please call your local orthodox rabbi!!!!!!!
Thateasy32 -“Is that a problem of moichek on shabbos?”
Why does everything become a Halachah question, when it’s a medical one? You don’t have to go into kid pullups, when they sell adult pullups! Use a small size.
Also, learn what to do about bed wetting. Eg. go to WebMd – children – bedwetting.
This IS a Halacha question and needs the psak of someone that is qualified to pasken.
Also, doing your own research is a great way to keep yourself informed, do NOT rely on any online sites for diagnosis and treatment.
2scents -“This IS a Halacha question and needs the psak of someone that is qualified to pasken.”
My point was – that you don’t need to go into things that could be a Shailoh. And I thought that my point was obvious!
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.