Allow me first to indicate that R’Zvi Hirsch Kalisher was a talmid muvhuk of R’Akiva Eiger and R’Akiva Eiger calls him “Rav chavivi kenafshi,moreinu verabbeinu” (!), so please do not assume he is to be dismissed easily.He discusses the ‘sholosh shevuos” (so beloved by latter-day kano’im) in his Perek “Shaar Zion” and conclusively shows that Rav jehuda’s ma’amar was only valid in his days because , in his day, most of the yeshivos were in “bovel” and hence, Rav Ze’ire (his baal pelugto) should not have gone to Eretz Yisroel in that era.
ROB: You seem to have an infinite amount of time to devote to this ideology. All the mainstream rabbonim disagreed with him. You had to dig up some not well known mechaber of two hundred years ago.
This is misleading as well. Put Reb Akiva Eiger in context. Mention all the titels he bestows on people throughout his responsa. Mention that most responsa written in that era contained lines of praise.
Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
The topic ‘R. Z.H. Kalisher's answer to "Sholosh shevuos"’ is closed to new replies.