- This topic has 29 replies, 19 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 4 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
its so disturbing that everyone HAS TO go to E”Y for sem. why cant anyone encourage american seminaries like Yavne, By intensive…and others.
It’s a fad. There is no real reason why everyone or most girls should go to EY for sem.
Because we richies like forcing other people to go into debt to have to keep up with us. That’s how we do things.
omg social status is not the only thing to care about in this world!! I used to be so sucked into it thank GOD im done with that…
SOme1 needs to start a topic about social status!
Do all guys still have to go to E”Y for yeshiva?
Chacha5
Go ahead see if you can convince enough girls to stay.
CRuzer: It is a different issue for guys, who it can be more beneficial too due to the potentially greater ability of Limud Torah in E”Y.
Not everyone can afford to go to seminary in Israel and there are plenty of people that send their daughters to local seminaries.
I don’t know where you live, but just so you know in NY the “fad” has died down to a large extent. I went to a big Bais Yaakov in Brooklyn and only twenty people went to E”Y out of my entire grade. In fact, there was a lot of peer pressure to stay back.
its so disturbing that everyone HAS TO go to E”Y
What’s really disturbing is that everyone isn’t living in E”Y already.
“What’s really disturbing is that everyone isn’t living in E”Y already.”
Yes, we need moshiach to come already. But we are discussing seminary in Israel, not living in Israel.
It is ok to say that it is hard that you are feeling forced to send your daughter to Eretz Yisrael for seminary. It is ok to bring in ideas in The US IT IS NOT OK TO SAY THAT GIRLS SHOULD NOT GO TO SEMINARY IN ERETZ YISRAEL. There is nothing in the world that can compare to spending a year in Eretz Yisrael. Although there are great seminaries here and yes, maybe more girls should start going if their parents cant afford seminary in Eretz Yisrael but there is something that the enviroment there does for someone that no where here can accomplish no matter how special and incredible the place. Sorry….
chacha5 you are very right! I agree with you very much! I think that concept has gotten better especially this year! I come from a place where it is unheard of not to go to seminary in Eretz Yisrael and this year I was surprised to hear that quite a bunch didn’t! so I guess every person needs to weigh for themselves if it is something they can do or if they need to settle on somewhere here. What is happening is crazy… I agree.
There is no real reason the vast majority of girls cannot go to seminary in America rather than in EY. They would get the same thing here as there.
how are dorms in Israel? What are the dorms of Ateres, Meohr and Darchei Binah like?
Candy613 made a great point, a year in Eretz Yisrael is incomparable, and leaves a lasting impression. If it is too expensive, perhaps American sems organise trips out there so some young women can experience Israel if they have not done so before.
Parents should not be pressurised into paying for any sort of fad, a year abroad, fancy car or over the top wedding, they also need to show unity in number and not pressurise each other into comparing simchas and spending. It does happen and not just among kids!!
You can NOT compare a girl that went to seminary to a girl that didnt. Everyone should try there hardest to send their child to seminary, the results are life transforming. Their are many ways to get scholarships paying for most of the cost. For example, SAT’s.
candy613. As a boy I have many friends whose year in Israel caused more spiritual negatives than positives. I could hypothesize that it was a lack of supervision, an independence, whatever it does not matter. The point is that every individual has to make a wise, guided decision and your jingoist Utopian view limits people from making those important decisions. In my personal opinion, sometimes more can be gained from choosing to make those decisions than from living in Eretz Yisroel for a year.
what happened to good old gateshead?
Yeah I heard great things about that one too!!! And also Bnos Chaim in Lakewood!!!
hey hey, who ever said that u have to go to E”y?? so not true i know plenty of girls who have gone to america, gatestead and there is nothing wrong with that, there just happens to be more sems in E”y.
hatzlocho
Looks like Yavne Sem is rebuilding. They made open houses in ny and lakewood. They announced that there will probably be a trip to E.Y. in the middle of the year for a few weeks, chaperoned and at no extra tuition cost (besides for a group rate ticket). Sounds worth exploring if you’re staying in the US.
when my sis was sem age abt 8 years ago, her whole grade went 2 israel except 2 girls. This past year, only 20 girls out of 65 in the grade went to israel.
so the fad is dying down- im glad
fyi Gateshead New is the most amazing place on the planet earth
Zeena: ateres’s dorms are just dorms, not too fancy, not too bad. Meohr’s are very nice. Darchei binah’s are more like apartments, and can also be nice–depends a lot on if you’re with girls who like to keep everything clean and neat or not, because there are a lot of kitchens which can get messy if you don’t take care.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.