- This topic has 12 replies, 13 voices, and was last updated 12 years ago by .
-
Posts
-
True or False?
Shmoel how about a translation so we can all answer the question.
depends on the yid
It’s a matter of perspective. Everything can be “shver” if you have that outlook in life.
True or false, that is a terrible statement to make, and has caused many people to abandon yiddishkeit.
There are many Rabbonim who say that statement brought down hundreds of people from Yiddishkeit!! It’s all how you look at things…..
Some of the most difficult things in Yiddishkeit, are so great and beautiful.
maybe it is shver but it is shvigger to be a goy
Mein shver zein a Yid echet. 🙂
Chacham- LOL 😉
Rabbi Chaim Shmuelevitz zt”l , former Mirrer Rosh yeshiva, once quipped , that though it perhaps might be shver tzu zein a yid, but that’s because people want to live a gashmiusdig leiben.
Who said we should dedicate our lives to physical pleasures? If we wouldn’t indulge so much into the mishigassin of the world to be so involved in cars/houses/gadgets/sheitels/clothes/money etc, and be more “into” ruchniyusdig things, you’ll discover that life isn’t that bad after all….?
That is an expression you should NEVER say, especially not in earshot of your children!!!
Tragically, many parents say it ALL the time in front of their kids as they are growing up, – and then they wonder WHY their kid decided to go off the derech!!!
What kid (OR ADULT) wants to live on a derech he’s been taught his whole life is shver?!?
What kids SHOULD BE hearing all the time is -IT’S GREAT TO BE A YID! IT’S A JOY to be a Yid! We are so fortunate to be Yidden!!! – AND… it can’t just be words, it’s what needs to be SEEN in the home!
“Shmoel how about a translation so we can all answer the question.”
Siz shver tzu tzein ah Yide = It’s hard to be a Yid.
And….FALSE!! It’s a challenge sometimes, but not “shver”. And the difference is that “shver” has a negative connotation, it’s associated with hard in the burdensome, painful sense.
A “challenge”, however, is usually more of a pleasurable engagement even though it isn’t necessarily easy.
I once heard “Siz shver tzu zein a halbe yid” but it’s not shver to be a whole yid.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.