August 12, 2011 8:26 pm at 8:26 pm #598602kol daveedMember
A little article I stumbled upon on a slow Erev Shabbos. Reposted from thejc.com (The Jewish Chronicle Online):
By Tim Alper, May 12, 2011
The South Korean ambassador to Israel, Ma Young-sam, raised eyebrows recently when he told reporters the Talmud was mandatory reading for Korean schoolchildren.
South Korea is a country with a deep Buddhist history, but one which has embraced with vigour the Christianity brought to its shores by missionaries in the late 1800s. Official statistics say some 30 per cent of South Koreans are church-going. In such a country, Jews are few and far between.
Yet, pop down to the local corner shop and along with a pot of instant rice or dried noodles, you can buy a copy of Stories from the Talmud. It is not rare, either, to come across book-vending machines stocked with classic works of Babylonian Judaism.
The Talmud is a bestseller in South Korea – even the government insists it is good for you, and has included it on the curriculum for primary school children.
Lee Chang-ro heads a literature research team at the Ministry for Education. He says: “The reasons why Korean children are taught Talmud are pretty obvious. Koreans and Jews both have a long history of oppression and surviving adversity with nothing but their own ingenuity to thank. There are no natural resources to speak of in Korea, so, like the Jews, all we can develop is our minds.”
The fascination with Judaism does not end there. Media outlets regularly run newspapers columns on “Jewish education”, weekly radio features, and television documentaries, all of them showing Jews in a glowing light.
The Talmud on display in a Korean bookshop
But although average Koreans can boast that their bookshelves hold at least one or two copies of the Talmud, to think of Korea as a hotbed of latent Judaism would be wrong. The motivation is less to do with religion and more to do with aspiration. Korean parents value schooling above all else. Parents send their children to after-school crammers until midnight and will spend their last penny on tutors and extra lessons. And, shy of good role models on the quest to securing academic success for their offspring, mothers almost unerringly turn to the Jews for inspiration.
Mother-of-two Lee San-sook explains that the way that Jewish children are brought up is universally viewed as positive in Korea.
“The stereotype of Jews here is that they are ultra-intelligent people. Jews have come out of nowhere to become business chiefs, media bosses, Nobel Prize winners – we want our children to do the same. If that means studying Talmud, Torah, whatever, so be it,” she says.
Nonetheless, for a small number of Koreans, this love of Jewishness does translate into religious observance, even though, with no synagogues and no access to kosher food, they encounter almost insurmountable problems in leading a Jewish life.
One wannabe Jew, 38-year-old Park Yo-han, has handed in his notice at an investment bank to take the plunge into Judaism. He says he will go to New York, where he knows nobody, has no job prospects, just to follow his dream of Orthodox conversion.
“I’ve tried just about everything. Converting in Korea isn’t difficult – it’s impossible,” he says.
Jewish observance in Seoul is almost entirely centred on Friday night services in the back of a Christian chapel on a US Army base. Every week, the tiny congregation of ex-pats and locals flip pews containing hymns books and New Testaments to face a pokey little ark for prayers. At the end of the night, everything gets put back in place for Friday night Mass. If there was not a small Ner Tamid hanging above the ark, you really would mistake it for a cupboard.
Most of the regular and long-serving members of the congregation are non-Jewish Koreans – civil servants, doctors and a politician from the ruling party, who is currently squeezing in his attendance between bouts of campaigning for local elections. They have no wish to convert but they take their interest in Judaism seriously. Most boast impressive collections of Judaica and read Hebrew fluently.
Among their number is a living legend of Korean Jewry, Abraham Cha. One of the few Koreans who have actually converted, he is a regular fixture at the US Army base services.
An old man now, he still cuts a memorable figure. He has a wild beard, payot, tzitzit protruding proudly, and maintains an unrivalled personal library of Jewish books from around the world, which he has painstakingly collected.
Cha says he had to give up everything to become an observant Jew in Korea.
“My family don’t speak to me any more, I had to divorce my wife. I even had to stop working because they wouldn’t give me the day off on Shabbat or on Jewish holidays. My bosses couldn’t conceive what it meant to be Jewish.”
Although precisely what it involves to be a Jew eludes most Koreans, anti-Jewish feeling is almost unthinkable in this part of the world.
Says Seoul resident Naomi Zaslow, “If you refuse a plate of pork ribs here, people will be dumbfounded. If you tell them it’s because you’re Jewish, they’ll unfailingly look impressed and say: ‘Oh, you must be very clever’.”August 14, 2011 3:48 am at 3:48 am #901018marbehshalomParticipant
ACTUALLY the Korean cleaners in inwood ny called Aloha cleaners, the owner listens to Jewish music, while doing deliveries. i heard him playing u’nesane tokef and he said Korean and Jewish music are similar.August 14, 2011 12:01 pm at 12:01 pm #901019minyan galMember
Very interesting article. Who knew?August 14, 2011 6:01 pm at 6:01 pm #901020deiyezoogerMember
I read a while ago (sorry, can’t remember where) that they beleive the talmud is sharpening the brain so thas why they study it.October 25, 2012 4:48 am at 4:48 am #901021
I feel as though I have read this story before, but seeing it again, I am in awe of the dedication of these South Koreans. How inspiring that they are seeking to live an observant life in an environment that is not conducive to it! And more generally, the respect of the larger population for Jewish learning and culture is so beautiful it makes me tear up — how I wish the world was generally a place where people respected and had interest in the wonderful aspects of each other’s ways of life. I may sound sappy — sometimes late at night I wax idealistic, dreamy, and philosophical 🙂 Although the original post is a year old or more, I found it very moving as I read old threads in the Coffee Room this midnight hour…October 25, 2012 4:58 am at 4:58 am #901022gotbeerMember
How is Korean and Jewish music similar?
Did you ever hear ‘Gang em Style’ ?October 25, 2012 9:35 am at 9:35 am #901023just my hapenceParticipant
gotbeer – it’s ‘gangnam style’ not ‘gang ’em’…October 25, 2012 2:02 pm at 2:02 pm #901024interjectionParticipant
“Did you ever hear ‘Gang em Style’ ?”
Have you heard the latest Jewish cds? Some could be played in a club…October 25, 2012 2:43 pm at 2:43 pm #901025akupermaParticipant
From an East Asian perspective, we are quite different than the western Euro-Americans whom we live among. Similar to the East Asians, we value scholars over warriors (i.e. father look at their newborn sons and dream of learning with them, goyim is the same situation dream of teaching the kid to toss a ball or shoot a rifle). We also use “indirect” speech (this goes back to ancient times – and it drives most Americans crazy). We have a very long time frame of looking at history, unlike most westerners who “forget” after a few decades.October 29, 2012 5:10 am at 5:10 am #901027
That is fascinating…I would love to hear more about your experiences being Jewish in an East Asian environment!October 29, 2012 5:28 am at 5:28 am #901028
aurora: akuperma is not speaking from any experience in an East Asian environment. He is merely describing how East Asian gentiles view Jews differently than the Europeans and Americans the Jews live among.October 29, 2012 12:34 pm at 12:34 pm #901029
Hello The Litvishe Kiryas Yoelite,
Thank you for the clarification — I got a little confused there 🙂
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.