Tznius for bochurim in pools

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Tznius for bochurim in pools

Viewing 27 posts - 1 through 27 (of 27 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #609352
    blackhatwannabe
    Participant

    What is the level of tznius for yeshiva bochuim in the pool? Does he have to wear a shirt? Can he wear shorts down to the knee? What about in European countries where some places require one to wear a a shorter, form fitting swimsuit to their pools for hygienic reasons?

    #953737
    ubiquitin
    Participant

    Depends on the bachur

    No

    Yes

    Its fine

    hope this helps

    #953738
    WIY
    Member

    You didn’t ask if he has to wear his black hat. Why do you assume he doesn’t?

    #953739
    Juboy613
    Member

    ubiquitin: who are u to paskin i agree with wiy: they should hav wite shirts black hats and blazers if they are on tha madraiga

    #953740
    ChiYid
    Member

    Been swimming with roshai Yeshiva…they wear just bathing suits….Saichel, kinderlach, saichel.

    #953741
    WIY
    Member

    ChiYid

    I don’t believe you that he went swimming without his hat or at the minimum a black bathing cap instead of a Yarmulka.

    #953742
    ubiquitin
    Participant

    Juboy613, I was asked

    If I feel comfortable answering I answer If it is above my pay grade I’d pass it on.

    This one was easy

    #953743
    YW Moderator-42
    Moderator

    Rebbe used to swim with his jacket, tie, and hat. Oh hold, on, that was playing baseball…

    #953744

    You don’t have to wear a shirt, although a cap or something should be worn in place of a kippah. Take it from me, I’m a Rabbi (it says so in my title) B-)

    #953745
    ObstacleIllusion
    Participant

    I’m not sure why there would be a more stringent level on tznius than the standard bathing suit, or even “a shorter, form fitting swimsuit” when we aren’t makpid to have private mikvaos for men?

    #953746
    blackhatwannabe
    Participant

    ObstacleIllusion-Good point Should one have tznius in a mikvah or lockeroom? Should he try to be covered up at all time? If not, then what is the minimum level of tznius, whether it is a mikvah or lockeroom or pool?

    #953747
    Shopping613 🌠
    Participant

    Speaking of swimming in suits. The rag of my sleepaway camp, every year on the first day would jump in the deep end with E/T tie, suit, shoes, hat….cuflinks?

    Shopping613 [$]613

    The Awarder, President, and founder of SUC (Single Username Certificates)

    contact me to join.

    Current members:

    Me

    ShtickyGuy

    Aurora77

    #953748
    WIY
    Member

    Shopping

    Due pumpkin about your spool cheek.

    #953749
    Shopping613 🌠
    Participant

    WHAT? what the heck does that have to do with anything…it dosent even make sense….

    Shopping613 [$]613

    The Awarder, President, and founder of SUC (Single Username Certificates)

    contact me to join.

    Current members:

    Me

    ShtickyGuy

    Aurora77

    #953750
    blackhatwannabe
    Participant

    What is the minimum amount of tznius one must have in the pool and walking outside the pool? What type of swimsuit is allowed within the boundaries of Halacha (For example,lets say one wants to swim laps and a shorter tighter swimsuit is preferred)?

    #953751
    WIY
    Member

    Shopping

    I was saying to monitor your posts because spell check is changing words here and there.

    #953752
    ObstacleIllusion
    Participant

    You’re allowed to wear a speedo both in the water and on the pool deck. If you feel that to lounge about on the pool deck in a speedo is not bekovidik then feel free to wear a towel or robe. But in regards to halacha, it is perfectly acceptable to swim in a speedo and walk around the pool deck as well. You’re allowed to immerse in a mikva with other men present, so we don’t forbid nudity among men, but we do encourage a certain level of self-respect towards one’s body. That has much to do with the environment one is in. It is perfectly appropriate at the pool to wear a speedo.

    #953753
    blackhatwannabe
    Participant

    ObstacleIllusion-what Halachik basis is there for that? What is your source?

    #953754
    WIY
    Member

    Blackhatwannabe

    Listen the concept is one should be as Tzanua as possible at all times. Even in the mikvah one should make every effort to be uncovered as little as possible. Additionally one should not look at the uncovered bodies of the other people there certainly not at their makom…

    Regarding swimming there’s no problem wearing a normal bathing suit. As far as speedos I don’t know if they are mutar as they are revealing and the pool is not a mikvah. One may not change publicly by the pool where others will see his nakedness. If you want to see hilchos tznius check out halachafortoday dot com website. You can ask him any questions you have as he is very welcoming of questions and usually answers within a few hours.

    #953755
    Shopping613 🌠
    Participant

    I know WIY I know, I try to reread my posts before posting but I forget…its ussually only 1 or 2 words anyway….what did it do that time?

    Shopping613 [$]613 The Awarder, President, and founder of SUC (Single Username Certificates) contact me to join.

    Current members: Me ShtickyGuy Aurora77

    #953756
    blackhatwannabe
    Participant

    WIY-I hear your point and that is why I questioned ObstacleIllusion. ObstacleIllusion-I am still waiting to hear your Halachik basis.

    #953757
    takahmamash
    Participant

    Is there such a thing as a schvimkleid for men?

    #953758
    ObstacleIllusion
    Participant

    Blackhatwannabe- At the moment, I can not give you proper sources in halacha. That aside, I would not trust a message board for halachic psak.

    #953759
    blackhatwannabe
    Participant

    Agreed but I just wanted to know the basis behind your opinion.

    #953760
    Sam2
    Participant

    See Mishnah B’rurah 2:1. Also, a speedo should always be Assur. Niddah 14b.

    #953761
    Juboy613
    Member

    ubiquitin:not so simple after all eh? wat about tznius in lockerooms?

    #953762
    ShalomToYou
    Member

    ChiYid is right.

    This whole thread is bizarre.

    I just want to point out that the question comes from today’s warped Hashkafa of equality. If women need Tznius why not men also? Just like WoW and their Tefillin

Viewing 27 posts - 1 through 27 (of 27 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.