- This topic has 29 replies, 21 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 6 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
You just found out that your live-in maid assumed to be a non Jew is in fact Jewish. What Halachachic problems can you think of that would need to be avoided if you planned on keeping her?
Yichud, yichud and yichud. It’s a d’oraisa, so your problems start and end there.
You can’t marry her to your eved ivri anymore.
Ok, you cannot force the two of them to marry anymore.
If you have her working for you on shabbos you can’t allow her to use hot water for the dishes, etc.
Yichud applies regardless.
She can’t be your Shabbos goy.
You probably have to encourage her to become frum, including routinely treating her as a guest on Shabbos.
if you bash out her teeth and poke out her eyes, she’s still yours.
There may be “Lifnei Iver” issues if you provide food (and otherwise she wouldn’t be eating then), since she will not be making brachos.
IIRC, the dinim of “BYomo Titan Scharo” are different.
In general, a frum Jew is prohibited from giving or selling food to a non-frum Jew since he won’t be making a brocha? How then can they be invited for a Shabbos mean or sold food in a frum grocery?
There may be “Lifnei Iver” issues if you provide food (and otherwise she wouldn’t be eating then), since she will not be making brachos.
I think only Rav Elyshiv holds this way, otherwise there would be much greater issues in general, like if you own a restaurant or work at one and obvious non-religious jews come in
There are many Mekilim for giving a food to someone who won’t make a B’rachah. First and foremost is the Netzi”v in Meishiv Davar Y”D 42 (maybe 52). If the person eating has a Din of a Tinok Shenishbah then there really is no reason to Asser here because they aren’t being Over any Issur so there’s no Issur M’sayeiya (there’s no Lifnei Iveir anyway even according to the Osrim).
But such a heter wouldn’t be applicable to giving or selling food to an off-the-derech or formerly frum person. Can a parent feed an OTD child?
It’s a d’oraisa
Considering that yichud was instituted by Dovid as a response to the Amnon/Tamar incident, how can it be said that it is d’oraisa?
The Wolf
Wolf the gezeirah of David was yichud penuya. Yichud isha is d’oraysa.
wolf- rashi shabbos yud gimmel amud alef.
Draft her into the Israeli army
Ve’Ahavta Lerayacha Kamocha. Love thy neighbor as thyself.
Ask Rabbi Fruchter what he did when he found out that his Shabbos Goy (Elvis Presley) was actually Jewish.
Wolf the gezeirah of David was yichud penuya. Yichud isha is d’oraysa.
Fair enough, but my understanding of a live-in maid is that they are usually single, no? If married, wouldn’t they live with their spouse?
Essentially any Derabbanan is a Deoraysoh of Lo Sasur.
While that is technically true, it is not applied for practical reasons. If you actually applied that reasoning, then there would never be *anything* that is d’rabbanan. You could never apply the rule of “safek rabbannan l’hakel” since every d’rabbannan is also d’oreisa.
The Wolf
what i think is the most obvious one-now you can have her cook for you
Though Dovid Hamelech was Giozer for a Pnuya, I believe that was one who is tahor. Nowadays all unmarried woman can be assumed not to be tahor so it may be min hatorah.
Sam2: ….whaat? the ‘king’ was jewish???
Elvis’ tzitzit were a little too progressive.
Wolf: Israeli Chareidi is correct.
Tzaddik: Elvis Aaron Presley’s mother was Jewish.
Sam2- Please expound.
What if you found out that your non jewish live in was jewish, and then she found out she was actually not jewish- what would she do?
Playtime: It has been disputed, but a biographer proved pretty clearly in the book Elvis and Gladys that Elvis’s mother was Jewish.
Essentially any Derabbanan is a Deoraysoh of Lo Sasur.
While that is technically true, it is not applied for practical reasons. If you actually applied that reasoning, then there would never be *anything* that is d’rabbanan. You could never apply the rule of “safek rabbannan l’hakel” since every d’rabbannan is also d’oreisa.
The Wolf
Actually, the Rishonim already ask about why we DON’T say that every Derabbanan is a Daoraysoh in respect to Sofek. I think it is a machlokes Ramban/Rambam if every Derbanan is in fact a Deorayso or not.
R’ Shimon Shkop (Sharey Yosher 1:3) and the Shev Shmaytseh (1:23) bring the various shittos down.
1) The Rabanan were never Goizer in a case of Sofek
2) Being oiver misafek is not included in “Lo Sosur” (For explanation of this, see the Nesivos who takes on that the Rebanan cannot “asser” something; you just have to listen to them. So if you are oiver beshoggeg, for example, you will not be oiver on Lo Sassur. See Kovetz Shiurim — Kuntras Divrei Sofrim.)
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.