- This topic has 65 replies, 16 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 5 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
In previous generations where yeshivas had eating days and people frequently fasted during the week because they had no food, over eating on Shabbos and Yom tov wasnt really a problem. People on the whole were under nourished. Today that isnt the case, nobody strarves during the week
Joseph:
There is evidence that Americans are overweight but not frum Americans any more than others.
How do you know? Did you conduct a scientific survey? Can you quote a reputable survey that reaches such conclusions?
I think the burden is on you, TM.
Americans generally are overweight, however in the NYC area not as much. NYC living requires more walking and other behaviors the lower the obesity rate. Down south especially people are extremly overweight, until you travel to these places you havent got a clue how bad it is
Why wouldn’t a fat person need a bigger jacket as well?
Although I won’t blame Chulent specifically as it’s actually a HEALTHY food unless you overload it with fatty meats or potatoes, many frum men are indeed overweight. In this case tzuros rabbim is not a nechama as everyone with weight related health problems will need to contend with them ON HIS OWN.
Based on no relevant statistics for comparison, and since the American percentage of the population that’s obese is high and climbing further, I think everyone should use their scale & BMI as a barometer and not sugar coat (pun intended) the reality.
However ZD be aware that sushi is generally more harmful to the waistline than chulent.
Eating ANYTHING when full after a meal goes well beyond what the Rambam recommends, so overeating is not a Jewish middah. We have to get back to our mesora and stop the madness — easier said than done obviously.
Is that a chiddush? Does it in any way back your assertion that frum men are fatter and unhealthier than the rest of the population? Or perhaps I misunderstood, and you didn’t mean to assert that?
This a a typical shabbos for many frum men
Go to Shul and after Shul there is a full hot kiddish, complete with Chulent, Kugel, Cake really enough for a full meal
Go home and eat ANOTHER full meal including chulent, Kugel , cake, bread and more
meal will finish at about 2, take a quick nap and then
eat ANOTHER full meal before 5:30ish (this time of year) .
And then later eat MORE food at night for Meleva Malka.
You have basically eaten 4 fully loaded meals without any exercise
mammale
While Id love to eat Sushi, a nice bottle of French or Italian wine with a nice thick juicy steak every day of the week, that just isnt happening, doesnt work on my budget or my health.
DY: who was your last comment directed at?
Whether one has a pear shaped or apple shaped (fatter midsection) body which I’d assume effects pants size is determined largely by genetics. In any case the latter is at greater risk of getting heart disease and diabetes. Since we can’t manipulate genes to change fat storage placement at this time the “Apple type” that are overweight need to lose the extra weight ASAP to remain healthy bezras Hashem.
I’m surprised nobody mentioned anything about being against Sunday night Cholent?
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.