- This topic has 16 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 2 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Why are 4 out of 5 Megilos in Kesuvim, and only Yona in Navi?
All 5 megillos are in K’Suvim (Esther, Rus, Koheles, Shir HaShirim, and Eichah), and Yonah is not a megillah.
I think you might be a bit confused. All five megillos are in Kesuvim. They are:
Koheles
Rus
Shir HaShirim
Eicha
Esther.
Yonah is in Navi because, well, Yonah was a prophet and had a prophetic message.
The Wolf
it’s not a megilla
all five megillos are in kesuvim
Shir hashirim
rus
eicha
koheles
esther
yonah is a haftarah which are all from navi and it is not a megilla
That would be because Yonah isn’t one of the meggilos. They are Eicha, Rus, Shir HaShirim, Koheles, and Esther and are all Kesuvim.
G’mar Tov
Um, Yonah isn’t a Megillah, it is part of Trei Assur……the 5 are: Esther, Rus, Eicha, Koheles, and Shir HaShirim !!!!!!!!!!!!
Wow. Everyone is Mechaven to the same ‘Terutz’!
But Sof Davar, on Shabbos Mincha we are Maftir from Kesuvim.
on Shabbos Mincha we are Maftir from Kesuvim.
You lost me on this one. Normally there is no Maftir on Shabbos afternoon (except in the event that it is Yom Kippur — and then we lain from Navi, not Kesuvim). In fact, the Haftorah NEVER comes from Kesuvim.
The Wolf
ok, I’ll bite. when do we do that? and also how could we be maftir on kesuvim if the bracha is asher bocher beneveim tovim?
Because 3 out of the 5 Trei Ossor are in the Torah and only Ezra and Nechemiah are in Tehilim.
Have a look at Shabbos 24 in the bottom Tosafos.
is that a joke?
Have a look at Shabbos 24 in the bottom Tosafos.
— and Gemara, and Rashi.
sorry that was for on the ball
HaLeiVi, I looked it up, very interesting. I dont know any shuls who do that now so what do you mean we? also i wonder what bracha they made
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.