Mosh85

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Eating in Sukkah on Shemini Atzeres #899038
    Mosh85
    Participant

    (From Artscroll Book on S.A)

    A. If its Sukkos you must live in the sukkah

    B. If its S.A sitting in the sukkah is belittling the holiday.

    4. Mordechai/Ravyah- Not saying the bracha alleviates the issue of belittling S.A b/c by not saying one you indicate that you are just in the sukkah b/c of a doubt which is not considered belittling.

    5. Basically:

    A. Sitting in the sukka for both meals is based on this idea that just not saying the bracha makes it not a zilzul.

    A. You say Shecheyanu at night for S.A so how can you say that in the sukkah.

    B. Its reasonable to say a person would eat in the sukkah if not obligated but not to sleep.

    8. The Gra and others (see Shar Hatzion there) say to sleep in the sukkah

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)