again I see that you are writing a questionable post
this time not pertaining to halacha but to
plain common sense and plain reality
—
tunafish writes :
Fighting in the idf has nothing to do with Zionism and everything to do with pikuach nefesh and protecting jews not the Zionist state.
—
you write:
If any Jews feel their life is at imminent risk, they can simply get into a plane and flee or escape into Jordan or Egypt ….
The reason for fighting in the IDF is to keep the zionist state in power.
====
so the obvious question which mr somejew is obligated to pose to himself is :
what in your opinion exactly is going to happen when IDF is stopping to fight ???
is there going to be pikuach nefesh or not ???
will eight million jews simply get into a plane ??? — to where , if I may ask ???
will eight million jews escape in to jordan or egypt ??? — will they safely let eight million jews in ???
can you , somejew , personally guarantee that nothing will happen to those eight million innocent brothers of yours ???
====
or are you , mr somejew , relying on a certain anonymous maharal here , which supposedly paskans [?] that eight million jews should rather die , better than the IDF should fight ???
if you , mr somejew are relying on this maharal [or rather on your own understanding of it] and really prefer them dying , over the IDF’s continued fighting ,
then why don’t you say so clearly ???
why do you come up with those blatantly unachievable solutions ???
please ,spell it out
come on , say the following loud and clear , bepeh malei
“According to somejew’s understanding , when faced with a choice between
A] IDF continues to fight, and
B] eight million jews are massacred
—————————- we should choose B”
.
.
.
any further comment seems superfluous ………………….
.
.
.