Reply To: Why did kimchis have seven sons who were kohen gadol

Sam, DY,

I read the teshuva. It seems reasonable that the same standard should apply to gemara and torah–that is, I don’t see why you’d need a peirush to make a siyum on torah any more than on gemara.

But I don’t even think he is saying you need a peirush to make a siyum on torah. I read that he is saying that if you teaching according to a peirush, it has to be from a legitimate one and not from the ones that are ?????.