PAA: Of course we can’t decide that they are wrong (well, unless we have a Ra’aya Muchrach from Shas, which if it actually is presumably they would be Chozer if we presented it to them). But we are certainly allowed to ask questions. LF seems to think that we can’t do that. (This reminds me of the comment I once heard someone make when they called someone a Kofer for asking a Kashya from a Gemara on a P’sak of R’ Chaim Kanievsky.)
Menu