oomis,
Joseph took the words right out of my keyboard.
Anyone who has not “learned the sugya” has no right to offer an opinion on a halachic matter. Your “feeling” has ZERO impact on the halacha & you only embarrass yourself by expressing it without a major disclaimer.
Your opinion on this issue is worth as much as R’ Chaim’s opinion on how to best create a scrumptious mushroom quiche.
Leave the Shulchan Aruch issues to those who have been through it a few hundred times.