newbee
that is not all you did.
You are either not aware that mesials Yesharim is by definition not miikar hadin
OR you are under the impression that it makes sense to hold people youve never met to lofty standards.
Either way you are being silly.
And yes you did deny a mitzvas aseh
when I said “”Just by eating cheesecake and baked ziti [on shavuos], and enjoying it you get schar!”
you replied “oy vey”
You said:
“Basically, you gave up on defending the main point, and started attacking me personally and about simchas yomtov- which has nothing to do with this. “
more silliness. YOU were the one who brought up yom tov: http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/halachick-dinner-what-do-you-think-about-it/page/2#post-570268
You do deserve attack regarding simchas yom tov since denying it is borderline kefira. There is a very real mitzva to have physical enjoyment on Yom tov. It worries me about our chinuch system that you have trouble with this very basic idea.