Reply To: Cholov Yisroel and Gan Eden

Syag: The fact is that many people who hold, and their Rov holds, that Cholov Stam is permitted still are machmir and refrain from eating CS either sometimes, or regarding certain foods [i.e. plain milk], or certain times [i.e. aseres yemei hateshuva] or any number of other conditions where they’ll refrain from eating CS even though other times they will eat CS as they hold it muttar.

So the question certainly is a relevent one.

Are these people being foolish for refraining from always eating and enjoying CS?

(Or Cholov HaCompanies, whichever nomenclature floats your boat.)