Reply To: Cholov Yisroel and Gan Eden

DM, ubiquitin: I see, there should never be halachic discussions since everyone has a Rov. The CR should be for politics only. That’s simply wrong. There are many halachic discussions and this is one of them. No one should be paskening off this. But this is certainly a legitimate issue and discussion.

Let’s put aside the gan eden/olam haba issue, if that’s contentious. But the question whether someone who holds CS is muttar has any reason to refrain from eating CS, either all the time or some of the time, is a very relevant question and point to many people. If you hold that CS is muttar wouldn’t you want to know if there’s ever any spiritual reason to spend more money on a gallon of CY milk or buy CY chocolate or ice cream rather than CS milk, chocolate or ice cream?