CS,
“As you can see, not only is it not strange to not sure with your Rebbe, is actually like rebelling against Hashem. So my logical conclusion is that maybe you don’t hold by the same level of respect for your Rebbeim because maybe you don’t hold as highly of them as tzaddikim? You can’t have it born ways – tell me I shouldn’t trust my own Rebbe”
Why is this a matter of “trust” ?
Can your or any rebbe ever commit a mistake?
Is it possible your interpretation on his words were in error? or in this case, at least retroactively in error?
In the very least – Is it possible to say that the Rebbe tried bringing Mosheach or in your case bring the Geulah and the Klipos/Sitra Achra Nisgabor and we simply weren’t Zocha?
Lastly, and most importantly – is your rebbe a Navi?
And if yes – please describe how you define a Navi and Nevuah?