Reply To: This Beer Predicament

FNY: We get what you’re saying; it’s your willingness to chose your own psak over that of the kashrus industry that’s problematic. Your own words were, “You, and everyone else, should follow your *own* rabbi’s opinion. Even if he’s wrong. ” This would seem to imply you have an actual opinion that’s matir? Would you care to share it? If not, then aren’t you just blatantly going against what you preach and and refusing to follow your Rabbi’s opinion because you think he’s wrong?

Also, the guy is vadai Jewish. Go back to saying it’s a safek if it was bought on Pesach or not (which could still be mitigated, by the way). There’s no safek if the owner is Jewish or not. Period. That’s the whole reason this situation exists.