Reply To: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us!

A freilichen Chanukah! Sorry haven’t answered in a very timely fashion – been very busy lately and probably will be the next few days as well… So if I don’t get back to you right away on something, its not because I’m shying away, its just because I have other matters to attend to first 😉

Al rishon rishon:

“CS, Chossid and SH (and maybe TT too), are you going to reply/comment on my claim/proof that the sundial story is fiction, or are you just going to ignore it because when a fact doesn’t fit in with what you want to believe the best thing to do is to ignore the fact?”

Rso the reason I didn’t respond further is because i didn’t see anything that warrants a response. Ie if you trust your third grade science experiment knowledge and the grand expertise of your third grade teacher, especially when sun dials are not even in use nowadays, to such an extent that you think that proves the entire Frierdiker Rebbe’s Memoirs are fiction, all it shows is the lengths you are willing to go to believe anything other than what our holy Rebbeim have said.

Ie you’re being the illogical one here. And I think you’ve shown that unhealthy level of skepticism of anything a lubavitcher says, many times over. It gets to a point where I think there’s no point answering your question because you probably believe I’m a paid lubavitch propagandist who is dishonest etc 😂.

Now if you could show an actual discrepancy in events written by the Frierdiker Rebbe himself in two different places or some other impossible contradiction that would warrant a more serious investigation. But you seem to be content to believe everything our chassidim and Rebbeim said and wrote is delusion or fiction while I’m certain that that is complete garbage and falsehood….