Chossid: “I really think that there is something behind all these comments and complaints that you guys say against chabad, which might be something you’re upset about, or you don’t want it change your mindset, or you’re scared someone might mock you if you hold like this”
From the “What to Say to a Snag” handbook, response no. 143: Tell them that they are just scared to admit the truth..
I believe I’m speaking for more than just myself here. We are not “upset” about anything, and we certainly don’t want to change our mindset because we believe that lubavichers’ beliefs range from mild lunacy and denial of the facts to out and out apikorsus. You are one of the mild ones, but you still talk garbage when it comes to trying to “correct” our errant ways. The part I quoted above is just one proof.
“Rav Shtieman told them they shouldn’t open a separate one, rather they should send their kids to the chabad School. (I heard this from the shliachs son in law).”
The story may be true, I have no idea, but you don’t even realize how ridiculous it is for you to quote a pro-lubavich story like that citing a lubavicher as its source!
“When someone does moifsim and has roach hakodesh”
I believe that Shabsei Zvi sr”y did all that too. It proves nothing. (And just to upset you, I am only using SZ as a rebuttal. Any resemblance to anyone alive or dead is merely coincidental.)
“Now regarding the claims that the friediker Rebbe wrote negative about misnagdim. To my knowledge he only went against the haskalah movement ”
Read the book and you’ll see otherwise. Unless you try to claim that all the misnagdim of Shklov and elsewhere he discusses were closet maskilim…
“By you guys, there is a book that came out from professor Berger, saying our shchita is treif”
He may have written that, I don’t know, but don’t take the statements of one person as a proof to what all of us “snags” believe. For the same token I can claim that you are an Elokist.
“(Sundial we still have to figure out and discuss)”
I consider the sundial story of utmost importance, not something to be merely put aside for a while, as it shows how the Rayatz wrote fiction.