Reply To: In the Purim Spirit: Women are required to Ad dlo yada 😂🤣😂🤣

laskern – was avrohom mekayim the mitzvah of kiddush Hashem in Ur Kasdim when Nimrod threw him in the fiery furnace? He survived.

We must must assume (since avrohom – avrom at the time) kept all the mitzvos includiong d’rabbonon), we must assume he made a brocha al kiddush Hashem – and now he survived, was it abrocha l’vatala?

Your “mehalech” (approach) by ad dlo yada is that the mitzvah is only accomplished/completed when s/he falls asleep, so by kiddush Hashem it would only be completed when he dies.

Just as by ad dlo yada, you wrote “the part to fall asleep he was not mikayem’ likewise you must hold that Avrohom/Avrom was not mikayem the part of kiddush Hashem of dying.

Really?!