Reply To: What incitement??

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee What incitement?? Reply To: What incitement??

#1938660
smerel
Participant

When you see the events of last week you see another reason why the Torah only allows Beis Din to punish for garmey- borey hezeka and not groma

Once you can claim “you are guilty because you “caused” something” there is no end to what you can charge your enemies with Therefore if it isn’t clear garmey you can’t be punished for “causing” in this world. Plus there is no way to know what is someone else’s heart so “he meant to incite a crowd ” can not be decided by a human court.

(If some liberal politician said right before a BLM riot “We have to FIGHT police brutality. We have to FIGHT to make sure black lives aren’t lost at the hands of the police no-one would try him for incitement. The incitement charges are clearly being abused )

I don’t only mean Trump. The prosecutor said that he may charge people who were nowhere near police office Siticik at the time of his murder with murder-felony. That is so sedom like you see why the Torah does not allow human courts to punish for groma.

In general the abuse of “he caused” is an endemic in the American court system.