“Neville, you clearly misunderstood the sources”
What I’ve been saying is not an anti-Shmini-Atzeres-sukkah specific approach; it is the standard understanding of this halacha. You clearly know enough to have heard what I’m talking about. I don’t know why you keep avoiding the issue of doing it l’shem mitzvah.
You told me to look at the sources, I did. When those sources didn’t end up saying exactly what you wanted them to say, you decide to just accuse me of not understanding them.