CS: “The Rebbe said that we will see miracles and that Yidden are safe in EY”
Were those two people who were killed by missiles safe? And the others who died from heart attacks brought on by fear, or who suffocated in gas masks that weren’t properly fitted, or who died because they injected atropine, where they safe?
In simple English: if that is indeed what the LR predicted, he was wrong. And if YOU want to consider it nevua (I don’t, and neither do any of the other non-Lubavichers on this thread), then he is a novi sheker.
And again, I REMEMBER that he said no one will be killed, but that doesn’t really make a difference as I have just demonstrated that even according to you what he predicted did not come to pass.
“Chassidim decided that it must mean that there will be no missiles etc.”
Just as they decided that you can get answers from the LR via random opening of the Igros. Where did that come from? And don’t tell me the LR said it because I know that he didn’t. Over the years I have asked a number of Lubavichers for a source for that, and no one has ever given me a straight answer.
CS in reply to the following: “moshe rabbeinu didn’t die when he “disappeared”
I guess you missed the heavenly funeral bit. For starters”
Whoa! If I understood you correctly, you’re referring to the image the Sotton made of Moshe Rabbeinu being transported on a bier. So are you now saying that the LR didn’t die? Because if you are that puts a whole different spin on what you have been saying all along. And if you’re not, then there’s no comparison, because Moshe Rabbeinu did NOT die at that time.