@CS
All Your sources about ‘DISAPPEARANCES’ have No connection whatsoever to the Ramban who is talking about DYING before finishing the Geula .
A sloppy proof is BY DEFINITION — no proof !
Lehavdil the Xtians employ that same method . They bring one so called ‘proof’ , its sloppy and flimsy , not watertight , so they move on to the next one , and all you get at the end is a repetition of countless ‘non proofs’ which prove …. NOTHING .
On the other hand you have a clear RAMBAN .
And the clear HABAD shitah pre 94 ,accepting that Ramban
And a Rambam that a dead mashiach is no mashiach [hilch. melachim]
And a universal acceptance by klal yisrael bemeshech kol hadorot
Isn’t it obvious that the source of CS’s and all other habadi’s so called “Proofs” stem from their deep wish have their arrow surrounded by the appropriate circles ?
HOW BLIND CAN YOU GET ?
.