Reply To: Gedolei Poskim in EY Again: All Jews Are Forever Forbidden From IDF. Why?

@ somejew

Q is very clear .

So clear that I cannot understand what you dont understand.

You wrote that that the only recourse when threatened is running away giving presents or any shtadlanut besides for fighting.

Fighting is against the shavu’ot , AND EVEN PIKUACH NEFESH IS NOT DOCHEH THE SHAVU’OT.

Thats in short a summary of your writing.

And that last point which i put in bold , is THE ISSUE where you diverge from klal yisrael and all the talmidei hahamim and poskim.
—

Now – shulhan aruch clearly disagrees wiyh you on that very point

Shulhan Aruch mandates , violating Shabbos to physically fight against an enemy that attempts to seize even ‘kash vateven’ —since it begins with kash and ends with lives (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, siman 329).

Will repeat again :

mandates to …. physically fight against an enemy

.
.

and again:

… mandates to …. physically fight against an enemy ….
———————–

As simple a proof as can be ….

.
.
Am waiting for a response .
.
.
.