ZSK – “IDF service is a government policy and legal issue.”
—
Small but important fact reminder :
1] Before the SC in Israel overstepped its mandate given by the Knesset, and illegally cancelled the 50-year-old authority of Israel’s successive Ministers of Defense , there was a fully working arrangement , whereby only fulltime learners were deferring on a yearly basis and non fulltime learners enlisted , haredi or otherwise.
Just because the SC illegally cancelled this working compromise , that does not mean that haredim are legally obligated to follow suit.
—
2] Before the unelected SC in Israel overstepped its mandate given by the Knesset, and illegally cancelled the Tal Law, which was duly passed by a 51 – 41 vote in the elected Knesset [the only legal sovereign of the State] , there was a law on the books , whereby only fulltime learners were deferring on a yearly basis and non fulltime learners enlisted , haredi or otherwise.
The SC never received the power to cancel any laws, in any way shape or form , not from the Knesset nor from the Israeli voter.
Just because the SC illegally cancelled this law , that does not mean that haredim are legally obligated to follow suit.
.
.