PM- “Your conversation with another anonymous “talmid” UNDERMINES your position.”
I’m still waiting to hear fom Joseph about my offer to name the well known Rav and the retell the entire story to Joseph’s Rav. I’ll even name the Rav to your Rav or Bemused Rav or any Rav that anyone posts; this offer hardly undermines my position.
Truth be told, if only I was told of Rav’s Moshe’s shita by a Rav, it would have been enough; I would not have to see or hear anything else and if some anonymous person were to claim on the internet claimed that it was all bunk, then so what?
I haven’t even looked at the other mare m’komos yet because it doesn’t make a difference l’maise. But I will and let you know. But even without looking it uo, if I had to guess, I’d say the that Rav Moshe was referring to a scnerio where a wick was used. But again, it doesn’t make a difference.
And PM, you failed to address my points,,,”I don’t know why we needed all this machlokis; all anyone had to do was to talk to their Rav about the shita or ask anyone who was in MTJ.”
Well, have you?