Reply To: Dipping Bagels In Soup On Shabbos

this thread is specifically to exlude a Halachic discussion of the permissibility of dipping Challah in soup (see original post)

it is not a matter of chumras

feif un referred to using a tureen

without a tureen the issue is not clear cut and heavily depends on the way the ladle of the kli rishon is used

in my home the soup bowl is a kli sheni as the ladle is kept in the kli rishon and temporarily removed to pour the soup