Reply To: Eruv in Brooklyn

Home Forums Shabbos! Eruv in Brooklyn Reply To: Eruv in Brooklyn

#761491
david1999
Member

So we are to believe a kol korei over a teshuvah? Rav Moshe clearly mentioned to the rabbanim of Flatbush that his chiddush is contrary to the Achronim and that he really did not want to mix into the matter. Now you want us to believe that all of a sudden Rav Moshe would sign a kol korei that states that there is no halalchic basis to establish an eruv? Please, we all know that Rav Moshe would not sign on a akol korei containing such language.

[Actually, Brooklyn has the added benefit that since our mechitzos are at the waterfront, even Rav Aharon would admit that they are sufficient since there is no rabbim traversing them.]

minimally EDITED