Rav Hirsch continues:
Page 5 comment 16:
Page 6 comment 18:
“I am unaware of the circumstances which surrounded the eruv in Paris. But the information provided herein proves, ostensibly, that the authors of this work are not better informed. No meaningful point can be extrapolated from this case until all its specifics are revealed.”
Page 6 comment 20:
Page 6 comment 21:
” is inaccurate.”
Rav Hirsch is incorrect (see above).
Page 6 comment 22:
” is inaccurate.”
Page 6 comment 23:
” is inaccurate.”
Page 6 comment 24: